I bought the honey roasted peanut butter from the City Peanut Shop, and I have to say this stuff is awesome. Best ever. First all-natural PB I've tasted that'll get me off the Jif for good. And it's only $1.99 for that container.
Check this place out. 8th and Bannock. Lots of great homemade and house-roasted nuts and candy and peanut butter.